Analyzing the construction of a survey:
The difference in perceptions of the nature of “construction engineering system organization”
Which of the following options is close or similar to the nature of the organization of the construction engineering system?
A. A professional organization whose duties include training and improving the knowledge of members and monitoring the good performance of its members.
b. A trade union whose main task is to maximize the benefit of its members in front of other stakeholders of the construction industry.
c. A semi-governmental organization is responsible for part of the process of issuing permits and finishing works and building control alongside the municipality.
This is a question that was asked on 02/06/1400 at 23:00 to the members of the Construction Engineering System Organization in virtual networks, and by 02/13/1400 at 7:00 a.m., 3778 people have viewed it and 432 people have answered it. . (here)
The percentage of answers to each option is as follows:
Trade unions: 26 percent
Professional organization: 34 percent
Semi-governmental organization: 40 percent
The way the audience and construction engineering colleagues responded to this survey shows the difference in perceptions of the nature of the “construction engineering system organization”, which actually stems from the multiple tasks or the different performance of this organization in different fields.
In Article 3 of the Building Engineering and Control System Law, the establishment of the “Building Engineering System Organization” as a non-profit organization is proposed, and in Article 15, the duties of the board of directors of this organization are listed. However, the provisions of the Engineering and Building Control System Law and its executive regulations, on the one hand, and the subsequent approvals and memorandums of this organization have been such that it has brought forward the “conflict of duties” of this organization. A problem that seems to be one of the main reasons for poor performance and failure to meet expectations from this organization.
If we consider the most important task of a trade union to follow and maximize the profit of the trade union members, then the most important task of a professional organization is to educate and improve the knowledge and ability of the members and to supervise the good performance of services and compliance with the criteria and principles and standards of the profession. It seems that the simultaneous evaluation of these two duties will cause conflict, whether professionalism is concerned with “providing the benefit of the general public” but unionism seeks “the interests of the guild”.
Among the three proposed options, the “semi-governmental organization responsible for part of the process of issuing permits and finishing works and building control alongside the municipality” with 40% of the votes received the most opinion of the voters, which is a deviation and misinterpretation of the “Engineering and Building Control System Law” It is addressed in the “Executive Regulations of Article 33 of the Law” and its scope has been increased with a memorandum of understanding between the municipality and the Organization of Building Engineering System in the mid-80s. This misinterpretation and deviation in the transfer of a part of the task of control and supervision of building implementation from the municipality to the organization of the construction engineer system occurred while the said task is one of the inherent duties of the municipality and specified in the text of the laws and cannot be transferred to another group.
According to Note 7, Article 100 of the Municipal Law, the supervising engineer is an agent of the municipality as a control and supervisory agent on the way of implementation and construction operations, and is actually the agent of this institution and serves to fulfill this duty of the municipality, but the executive regulations of Article 33 and The subsequent approvals of this organization are interpreted as if the supervising engineer is the supervisory agent of the construction engineering system organization.
https://b2n.ir/e65755
@Farasakht_mag
This post is written by Mkd1396