Why are the points of some members in the supervision referral scheme negative?

Why some members’ points in the supervision referral plan are negative:

The exact formula for calculating points is:
(A-(B+C)×10000)/A

A: It is the basic monitoring capacity

B: It is the meter used in monitoring that has not been released

C: It is the area used in the design/calculation that has not been released

Used capacity means the meters of design/monitoring works that are still involved and have not been released

The following cases – citing case examples – are cases where the sum of B and C is better than A, so the score will be negative:

1. Civil engineering field:
For engineers who are qualified to calculate and monitor both at the same base
#Example: civil engineer level 1 calculation and level 1 supervision
Currently, the basic capacity of calculation for him is 16000 square meters, while the basic capacity of monitoring for this engineer is not more than 12800 square meters. The following cases are examples of #possible and #likely to have happened

The area used in monitoring is 4000 square meters and the area used in calculation is 13000 square meters.
The area used in the monitoring is zero square meters and the area used in the calculation is 15,000 square meters

In all these cases, the sum of the area involved in the calculation and monitoring of the basic monitoring capacity is therefore a negative score

2⃣ All disciplines:
Engineers whose design/calculation qualification base is higher than their supervision qualification base (of course, there is rarely such a situation)
#Example: Architect engineer level 1 design and level 3 supervision:
Currently, the basic design capacity for him is 16,000 square meters, while the basic supervision capacity for this engineer is not more than 8,000 square meters. The following cases are examples of #possible and #likely to have happened

The area used in monitoring is 7000 square meters and the area used in calculation is 8000 square meters.
The area used in the monitoring is zero square meters and the area used in the calculation is 9000 square meters

In all these cases, the sum of the area involved in design and monitoring is greater than the basic monitoring capacity, so it is a negative score

3⃣ All courses:
Design engineers who are still #members of a number of design bureaus with valid licenses and an increase factor (1.8) is applied to their design capacity:
#Example: mechanical engineer level 1 design and level 1 supervision
Currently, the basic design capacity for him is 28,800 square meters (the basic capacity is 16,000 meters multiplied by the office factor of 1.8), while the basic monitoring capacity for this engineer is no more than 16,000 square meters. The following cases are examples of #possible and #likely to have happened

The area used in monitoring is 9000 square meters and the area used in calculation is 17000 square meters.
The area used in the monitoring is zero square meters and the area used in the calculation is 25,000 square meters

In all these cases, the sum of the area involved in design and monitoring is greater than the basic monitoring capacity, so it is a negative score

Conclusion:

1. The negative score means that if, for any reason (categorized in the above examples), the basic design capacity of an engineer is greater than the basic capacity of his supervision, there is a possibility that the unreleased area of ​​the engineer (due to design) exceeds the basic capacity. If his supervision increases (even if they do not have any used capacity in supervision), then according to the above formula, his score will be negative.

2⃣ All engineers who have a negative rating have a zero rating and will not be placed in the supervision referral queue until their rating is positive after releasing the previous work.

The logic of this work is this: this engineer took advantage of the opportunity provided by the legal regulations and the basic capacity of the design is more than the basic capacity of the supervision. have not been released yet) has exceeded the total capacity of the monitoring base that it could have

This post is written by ashabibi1355